The Evidence Meter

Every investigation on this site rates the ingredients or mechanisms behind a claim on the same four-tier scale, so you can compare across articles at a glance instead of taking our word for it in prose.

Unsupported

No meaningful traditional use or research record we could find. Often a term or mechanism invented for marketing.

Traditional Use

Documented historical or folk use, often across multiple cultures — but little or no controlled modern testing.

Preliminary

Lab, animal, or small-scale human studies exist and show a plausible effect, but larger human trials are still missing.

Established

Supported by multiple controlled human trials, typically with a defined effective dose and delivery method.

A single article can rate different ingredients — or different forms of the same ingredient — at different tiers. Oral and topical doses of the same compound are never scored as equivalent evidence.

How we build an investigation

1

We watch the source claim in full

Whether it's a video, an ad, or a viral post, we document exactly what's said — including the specific mechanism, study, or story used to justify it.

2

We recap it accurately before we evaluate it

You get a fair, complete summary of the claim first. We don't evaluate a strawman version of it.

3

We check each ingredient against the published research

Peer-reviewed studies, clinical trials, and established toxicology and pharmacology references — not other blog posts.

4

We separate the claim from the ingredient

An ingredient can have real evidence behind it even when the specific story built around it doesn't. We score both.

Affiliate disclosure

Some investigations link to the product discussed, and we may earn a commission if you choose to purchase through that link, at no extra cost to you. That relationship never changes an Evidence Meter rating — the rating reflects the underlying research, not the product, and is written before any purchase decision is made. If a claim doesn't hold up, we say so, regardless of whether we have a financial relationship with the product being discussed.

What this site is not

This isn't medical advice, and it isn't a substitute for talking to a doctor about a specific health condition or medication. We rate the state of the public research — we don't diagnose, and we don't tell you what to do with your own health decisions.